Showing posts with label Climate Change. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Climate Change. Show all posts

October 11, 2013

As Climate Changes, will we Change our Temperament?

Written for SIEL by:
Andrea R. Herman, 2015


As Climate Changes, will we Change our Temperament?

If youve ever gotten mad at the rain, or felt like screaming as sweat drips down your face in a crowded coffee shop on a sunny day, you are living evidence that emotional turbulence matches periods of environmental turbulence around you. According to an article from TakePart, a study shows that interpersonal conflict and violence rise during periods of environmental unrest. The study suggests that there is a “surprisingly strong link between climate change and conflict on a range of scales -- from violent crime between individuals, to wars, and even the collapse of civilization.”


In the journal Science, UC Berkeley researcher Marshall Burke described a quantitative assessment made of 60 studies that showed a link between climate variables and conflict outcomes. All 27 of the studies that looked at the effect of hotter temperatures found that those temperatures cause more conflict; this research does not mean temperatures are the only cause of conflict, but the research is nonetheless indicative of a strong correlation. The study indicated that increases in temperature from present day until 2050 is likely to cause conflicts between ethnic groups and nations by as much as 56%, and interpersonal violence by as much as 16%. 

History evidences that climate has played a huge role in various conflict events. The collapse of the Akkadian Empire, sometime after 2,200 B.C., is considered to have been bolstered by prolonged drought. Domestic violence in Australia is linked to the unusual heat wave of 1992. Even hundreds of years of peasant rebellion from the 1400s to 1900s in China has been tied to the impact of continuous droughts and floods.

Of course, the study received criticism for its findings. One of the main disputes was over the study’s mistreatment of the subject-matter -- climate is not the same as weather. “Whereas weather is “atmospheric conditions over a short period of time, climate is how the atmosphere behaves over long periods of time.” Weather is what you live in, climate is what you predict. Nonetheless, the study’s researcher stated that "the relationship between climate variables and conflict shows up at a variety of time scales, from hourly changes in temperature to century-scale changes in temperature and rainfall."

Economic and humanitarian concerns must seriously be taken into consideration in assessing the link between conflict and climate change. "The costs of inaction are probably higher than we previously thought: "Our results suggest that rates of human conflict could rise relative to a world without climate change," Burke said. 
The evidence, even if only suggestive, tells us that it is time to act more diligently to combat climate change. 

What do you think about this evidence? 

Do you think it is obvious that climate effects our lives? 

Do you think our hormones or other physiological attributes change because of the environment and therefore make us more or less temperamental? 

Freedom of movement away from bad climates may limit conflict; if you have the means to move away from the rain, then you will be happier doing so. We must also consider those who are financially incapable of moving away from climates that make them unhappy. Will continuing environmental degradation resulting from climate change, as it already impacts impoverished communities (economies, resources, etc.), make those at risk even worse off?

Please send comments to siel@lclark.edu. 



1 Douglas Main. Hot and Angry -- Yes, Climate Change Could Increase Conflict. accessed on 10/11/2013 at http://www.takepart.com/article/2013/10/03/hot-and-angry-yes-climate-change-could-increase-conflict.

September 28, 2013

Sustainable Agriculture in the UN article

Written for SIEL by:
Andrea R. Herman, September 28, 2013



The UN Conference for Trade and Development recently reported in a 321 page document about sustainable agriculture entitled “Wake up Before it’s too late: Make Agriculture Truly Sustainable Now for Food Security in a Changing Climate”. The document consists of topics such as the range of benefits of locally developed plant varieties, carbon sequestration as social justice, and democratizing access to seeds and other products. The article argues for organic, low-input, small-scale agriculture as the best means for feeding the world and managing the stress of drought, rain, and other weather catastrophes that are brought about by climate change. Though the UN does not specifically endorse this document, having the organization’s logo on the cover of the publication carries significance. 
Two writers for the report, Miguel Altieri and Parviz Koohafkan, discuss a thesis regarding the importance of various forms of traditional agriculture found around the world. They argue for a focus on the history of adaptation, the ability of humans to adjust and adapt to the changing physical and material environment from generation to generation. Since our world will be reaching 8 billion, the need for adaptation is pertinent. Last year, the Director of National Intelligence’s Global Trend Report for 2030 singled out biotechnology as the most promising means for tackling climate change issues as the demand for resources increases and the supply decreases. Industrial agriculture, as Altieri stated, is not feeding the world -- “Most of what it produces is biomass, which is for cattle, biotech crops, and biofuels.” 
Altieri would rather see an approach to agriculture that takes into account the historical knowledge that we have gained over time. He bodes for the development of a western scientific approach based on the practices of other countries that have been pressed with agricultural changes and challenges.  The report also indicates a need to step away from a “green revolution” approach that was developed by Nobel Laureate Norman Borlaug in the 1960s. His approach was indicated by the transition of Latin American and Asian farming to modern hybrid wheat and rice varieties that were grown with irrigation and synthetic fertilizers and pesticides. The report critiques this approach, instead arguing for “ecological intensification.” 
The discrepancy between the two theories is only a means to change the conversation about how to approach issues of global agriculture. The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is working to continue the Green Revolution approach, but also is keeping in mind sustainability and biotechnology. They are working toward providing farmers access to seeds that are affordable, giving farmers the option of what strategy to use in obtaining he benefits of innovative farming practices. Perhaps the real focus should be on how to widely implement these ideas. Is the implementation based on politics, science, morality, or social movements? We need to change our attitude about chemical production of food to adapt to the struggles of our environment to handle such production methods, putting the focus on sustainable practices rather than merely altering the chemical structure of the foods we grow.



September 10, 2013

Palm Oil; what we can do

Written for SIEL by:
Emi Kondo, September 10, 2013






Harvesting palm oil in Southeast Asian has been a controversial issue for many reasons. The topic first drew media attention when the harvesting led to destruction of orangutan habitat in order to replace the natural forest with oil palm plantation. Many of these orangutan species, such as the Sumatran orangutan and the Borneo orangutan, are currently considered endangered. Habitat destruction makes these endangered species more vulnerable. Fragmentation of habitat not only reduces the natural habitat for these species but also allows easier access for hunters and traders. Many poaching occur in these areas because illegal pet trade is prevalent.


Recently, environmental groups have been highlighting another issue: effects of deforestation to the ecosystem. To convert the forest to a plantation, the palm oil industry sometimes sets forest fires to clear the forest. This practice clears the forest, but at the same time, burns many animals to death in the process. Also, scientists have warned about the effects of such practices because the forest fires increase the carbon dioxide emission, which contributes to the global climate change. Forests are large carbon dioxide sinks, and a plantation does not have the same capacity to sequester as much carbon dioxide as a natural forest. Lastly, the smoke from fire decreases the air quality in the area, affecting animal and human health.


In addition, switching from a forest to a plantation also reduces tree species diversity because the plantations use monoculture practices to maximize the profit from palm oil. For example, a state agency in Malaysia announced in July that oil palm plantation has driven a subpopulation of keruing paya in Peninsular Malaysia to extinction. The reduction of species diversity is problematic because a disease can spread far more quickly over a large area if only one species exist in the area; on the other hand, when many species occupy an area in a forest, different species can act as a buffer against spreading of a disease.


SIEL is starting a project this year to increase awareness of these issues on Lewis & Clark Law campus. Palm oil tends to be used in baked goods, lotion, and soap. We will initially target these products and ask the vendors to replace the item with a palm oil-free product. This project aims to eliminate any palm oil from the campus, as well as educate the students and the vendors on the current issues.

February 19, 2013

The Global Shale Initiative - “Balancing Energy Security and Environmental Concerns”

On August 23rd and 24th, the US Department of State hosted the first ever Global Shale Initiative under the theme “Balancing Energy Security and Environmental Concerns.” Over 50 delegates from 20 countries attended the meeting prominent amongst them were China, India, Poland and South Africa. Also in attendance were the EPA and 12 other USG agencies, oil companies with the fracking technology. 

Shale gas is natural gas formed as a result of being trapped in shale formations. The process used to extract shale gas is known as hydraulic fracturing or fracking. 
Hydraulic fracturing has become a contentious environmental and health issue throughout the world to the extent that France, Bulgaria and certain states in the United States like Vermont have banned the practice entirely, while some other countries and certain states in the United States have placed a moratorium on the practice to have ample time to carry further studies for purposes of making an informed decision.

Proponents of fracking were claiming before that no evidence has been found to prove that the process causes adverse environmental and health effects, thus implying that the process is safe. They also claim that developing natural gas using this modern technology will reduce dependence on foreign countries, create jobs and help in reducing green house gases. Right now they are saying that with effective regulations, fracking can be done safely.

On the other hand, those who are against it claim that it causes serious environmental and health risk such as water pollution, air pollution, increase of green house gases in the atmosphere, earth quakes and so on.


Here’s what I think was wrong with the Global Shale Initiative:
- Though the Global Shale Iniative included Environmental Concerns in its theme, no environmental organization was invited. The State Department invited the EPA, which has no regulation specifically on fracking, meanwhile state agencies which have some specific regulation on fracking were not invited.
- Also, Poland was among the countries invited and encouraged to develop it shale reserves. Poland gets most of its energy from Russia, if it can develop its shale reserves, it will become Energy Independent and less control from Russia.
- Also, the oil companies were invited to talk about the fracking technology and after the conference India, China and South Africa have invested million of dollars in these oil companies to get the technology.


Written for SIEL by:
Eric Denzel, 2012 L&C Alum

November 14, 2012

Coal: An Unwanted Relic of Yesteryear


There was a time in history when people didn’t have cars, when people didn’t have planes, and people rarely traveled more than twenty or thirty miles from their home. There was a time when most production came from a farm or a skilled tradesman. This all began to change starting with the industrial revolution, a revolution largely powered by coal.

Today, trips across the country and around the world are common. Today we can communicate instantly with anyone around the world. Today we even have boxes whose sole purpose is to record our favorite shows all so that we are not inconvenienced by missing them in the rush of our busy lives. Today a large percentage of energy still comes from coal, despite the introduction of numerous other technologies that could reduce the need for coal.

However, industry doesn’t want to hear this. For them, coal represents cheap profits. They choose to ignore the fact that when one looks at the big picture, coal is anything but cheap. Coal is shipped from where it is mined using coal trains. These coal trains spread coal dust along their route, increasing the risk of respiratory problems for people who live near them. Furthermore, there have been close to 20 coal train derailments this year alone.

Despite this, big coal companies such as Arch Coal and Peabody Energy are proposing to ramp up coal export to China. They seek to strip mine coal in the Powder River basin in Wyoming and Montana, ship them through the Northwest on coal trains that could each be over a mile long and have several export terminals along the northwest coast for shipment overseas to China. When China burns the coal they would not only be harming their already compromised environment, but the air pollution could then travel back across to Pacific, impacting air quality along the west coast. 

While it will ultimately be the U.S. Army Corps that decides whether to approve the permits for coal export terminals in the Pacific Northwest, the resulting harm will be felt not only here, not only in China, but also globally.  The increased consumption of coal exacerbates a planet already facing climate change crisis. The reality of China's environment and the global issues related to these proposals are addressed by Izzy, an international student, in her recent testimony at the November 3rd Harbor, WA hearings.

As I said, coal became big during the environmental revolution, but it never took its cue to exit. Because of this, we are long overdue for another revolution, an environmental revolution where we once and for all make coal a thing of the past.


Written for SIEL by:
Juan Bacigalupi, 2L

October 24, 2012

Cap-and-Trade Pilot Programs Launched in China


China has proposed plans for its seventh carbon cap-and-trade program.  This month, Guangdong province joined six other cities and provinces in forming pilot programs to reduce carbon emissions in energy intensive industries.  Guangdong’s participation is significant because the large southern province is a national industrial powerhouse for China and includes the economic miracle city, Shezhen. 

The pilot program is voluntary, but four cement companies have already formally signed on.  TaPai Group, HaiLuo Cement, ZhongCai Cement, and HuaRun Cement have joined together in a 1,300,000 ton carbon dioxide cap. The companies all intend to add new production lines and establish carbon emissions targets.  A representative from ZhongCai Cement pointed out that, although there will be increased production expenses for meeting emissions targets, the company will benefit from raising the bar for the whole industry’s energy efficiency.  A permanent emissions trading program would create a barrier to entry for new or smaller cement companies. 

Coming towards the second half of its 12th five year plan (2011-2015), China’s pilot carbon emissions trading programs focus on bringing communications, transportation, and construction industries under cap-and-trade limits.  One of the hurdles for any new carbon exchange program is a lack of historical data. The Guangdong’s pilot program includes mostly factories that are not accustomed to monitoring emissions and so do not have years of data to base a market price for carbon credits on.  Currently, 90% of the companies participate in the program for free, while 10% pay according to an international market price.  Other questions remain as to what penalties will be in place for companies that fail to meet their carbon quota and what role will the government play in the carbon trading system. In any case Guangdong faces the huge challenge of attempting emissions reductions while encouraging increases in industrial and economic growth.  China intends to have a national carbon exchange program in place by 2016.  How the relatively wealthy Guangdong province decides to carry out its carbon exchange program will mean a lot to other provinces making similar decisions.

Interested in more? Feel free to visit posts by beyondbrics & Between the Poles.


Written for SIEL by:
Althea Mickiewicz, 1L